DCI Dialogue

Sort by:

RSS feeds

DCI Dialogue

Andy Levine

Subscribe to RSS Feed
andy.levine@dc-intl.com

June 28, 2010 12:04 PM

The Idea Incubator Goes to Campus
June 28, 2010

The New York Times had an interesting article over the weekend about how universities around the country are now working closely with investors to ensure that promising ideas are nurtured and turned into successful start-ups.

Bob Tedeschi reports that the difference between these academic “proof-of-concept centers” and traditional business incubators is that they get involved in a much earlier stage. He writes: “Rather than offering seed money to businesses that already have a product and staff, as incubators usually do, the universities are harvesting great ideas and then trying to find investors and business people interested in developing them further and exploring their commercial viability.”

Andy Levine

President/Chief Creative Officer

NYT Logo Cropped.jpg

The Idea Incubator Goes to Campus

By Bob Tedeschi

June 28, 2010

Douglas P. Hart, a professor of mechanical engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who sold his last start-up for a tidy $95 million, is already on to his next big thing.

On Tuesday, he expects to lock up $1.5 million in funding for his new start-up, Lantos Technologies. The company has developed a 3-D scanner that it hopes will streamline the current generation of earphones and hearing aids by precisely fitting them to the dimensions of the ear canal, right up to the eardrum.

“We’re hoping people will be able to walk in the store and have their ears scanned like people get their ears pierced today,” he says. “That’ll lower the cost because they don’t have to go to a specialty doctor.”

Unlike other academics often left to their own devices, Professor Hart was able to bring his hearing aid concept closer to reality with $50,000 in backing last year from the Deshpande Center for Technological Innovation, an M.I.T. entity originally funded by two private investors, Jaishree Deshpande and her husband, Gururaj.

“I wouldn’t have known the first thing about doing all of this,” says Professor Hart. “The people from the Deshpande Center led me through.”

By providing academics like Professor Hart a bridge to the business world, M.I.T. is in the vanguard of a movement involving a handful of universities nationwide that work closely with investors to ensure that promising ideas are nurtured and turned into successful start-ups.

At first glance, the centers look like academic versions of business incubators. But universities are getting involved now at a much earlier stage than incubators typically do. Rather than offering seed money to businesses that already have a product and a staff, as incubators usually do, the universities are harvesting great ideas and then trying to find investors and businesspeople interested in developing them further and exploring their commercial viability.

In the jargon of academia, the locations of such matchmaking are known as “proof-of-concept centers,” and they’re among a number of new approaches to commercializing university research in more efficient and purposeful ways — and to preventing good ideas from dying quietly. The first proof-of-concept center, the William J. von Liebig Center, was established in 2001 at the University of California, San Diego.

So far, the von Liebig Center has helped start 26 companies that have created more than 180 jobs and attracted more than $87 million in financing. Among those companies are Mushroom Networks, a developer of online video technology, and, more recently, Biological Dynamics, a maker of early cancer diagnostic technology.

“Many of the great ideas get stuck in labs because scientists don’t have access to the kind of ecosystem” that Deshpande and other proof-of-concept centers offer, says Amy Salzhauer, a founder of Ignition Ventures, an investment firm based in Boston and New York that works with scientists to set up companies. “This is a way to better harvest those ideas.”

While the von Liebig and the Deshpande centers are the highest-profile successes in this realm, similar entrepreneurial surges are occurring at other schools, like the University of Utah, Georgia Tech, the University of Kansas and the University of Southern California.

It’s an expensive proposition. Not including the cost of the technology itself, it can cost investors roughly $250,000 to determine whether an idea will actually blossom into something that can be sold, Ms. Salzhauer says.

Academics and others have a term for the chasm that usually separates a good idea from people who will invest in it: the “valley of death.” An increasing lack of interest in initial public offerings over the last decade has left even less money for early-stage companies.

But even in such a challenging fund-raising environment, analysts say many universities continue to embrace old-fashioned methods for supporting and promoting potentially lucrative in-house research. Many schools have what are known as “technology transfer” offices that introduce businesses and investors to patented university research and help schools strike licensing deals.

Corporate executives and investors complain that overly rigorous, or simply overwhelmed, tech transfer offices take too long to negotiate licensing agreements. And the offices often try to sell ideas with unproven commercial relevance.

“It’s the way engineering was 50 years ago,” says Mr. Deshpande. “They’d design something, and then hire marketing people to peddle it. You wouldn’t do that now without understanding the customer’s needs.”

A proposal from the Obama administration would experiment with all of this by allocating $12 million among several institutions next year in what proponents hope will be a continuing effort to support and study proof-of-concept centers. If successful, supporters say, universities could spread the model faster.

But the idea represents a shift in thinking about the federal government’s role in stewarding the more than $50 billion it gives to university researchers annually. Until now, that money has been for the discovery, not commercialization, of scientific breakthroughs.

The idea of government-backed proof-of-concept projects has plenty of proponents, including W. Mark Crowell, a University of Virginia executive and past president of the Association of University Technology Managers, and Lesa Mitchell, an executive at the Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation, which finances entrepreneurship research and programs.

Others believe that the experiment, while worth trying, isn’t likely to yield significant results.

Toby E. Stuart, a Harvard Business School professor who researches social networks and entrepreneurship, noted that virtually every government wants to replicate Silicon Valley’s university-driven system of innovation.

“But you can’t engineer it through policy means,” he says.

He thinks proof-of-concept centers would be more useful at universities other than the likes of M.I.T., Stanford and Harvard, which are already hubs in entrepreneurial clusters.

“But in any significant way, it will happen organically,” he says, “and not through some bureaucratic intervention.”

Indeed, organic progress is on display outside of some of the country’s big tech corridors. At the University of Utah, the Technology Commercialization Office helped arrange early financing and networking resources for 25 companies. The university’s president, Michael K. Young, aligned the office with the business school, and Brian A. Cummings, the office’s executive director, says the new arrangement allows researchers and business students to work together more closely.

Last year, business and bioengineering students who worked with Mr. Cummings’s office drew up a short list of promising research discoveries. One was an idea for a feeding tube that is fitted with a tiny video camera to help surgeons implant it more precisely. Dr. John C. Fang, a professor of medicine, first came up with the idea in 1999.

A team of graduate students then fashioned a business plan around the idea and shopped it to local venture capitalists. Dr. Fang says he expects to secure $1.25 million in financing for it soon.

Mr. Crowell, at the University of Virginia, participates in proof-of-concept review sessions, where academics and investors evaluate ideas. He says several projects that attracted $100,000 seed grants from the Wallace H. Coulter Foundation Translational Research Partnership have generated commercial licensing deals.

Among them is a project called HemoShear, which is developing a device that can decrease the time and cost needed to test new drug compounds.

And in Pittsburgh, a state-financed nonprofit group, Innovation Works, has invested $45 million over the last decade to help the area’s university researchers — and anyone else — prove their ideas and showcase them with investors. The companies have attracted more than $800 million in venture capital and have gone on to create 3,000 local jobs, says Matt Harbaugh, the chief investment officer of Innovation Works.

One company, Bossa Nova Robotics, is made up of Carnegie Mellon robotics researchers who had a commercial hit last year with a pair of toy robots, the Prime-8 gorilla and Penbo, a penguin.

University executives say they sometimes struggle to find motivated entrepreneurial professors. Medical researchers with promising discoveries may plunge into the marketplace out of a sense of service. For others, though, the motivation can be as simple as the sight of a fellow professor in a new sports car — a behavior common enough that it is known in university circles as “the Porsche principle.”

When Professor Hart first thought of the technology for his most successful product to date, an oral scanner, he was focused on pure research, not profit. But he found that he wasn’t entirely immune to a financial lure after learning that old friends at the California Institute of Technology had struck gold with some of their ideas.

“I was a little jealous,” he says. “I thought I’d try it.”

Although he wasn’t sure exactly how to get started, the Deshpande Center had recently opened. Krisztina Holly, then the center’s executive director, sent a request for proposals to faculty members.

After Professor Hart responded, he teamed up with Ms. Holly, who already had experience leading a pair of tech start-ups and had mechanical engineering degrees from M.I.T. After awarding Professor Hart a $250,000 grant, she also encouraged him to participate in a business-plan competition, where he mentioned his idea to a pair of Harvard M.B.A. students, Eric Paley and Micah Rosenbloom.

Professor Hart’s team incorporated the company as Brontes Technologies and tested more than 30 applications of his science, including technology for scanning faces in 3-D for security investigations. During that time, the team learned about the dental industry’s need for digital scanning technologies. So Brontes adapted the technology for use in an oral scanner that could create images of the mouths of patients who needed new crowns on their teeth.

Next came an introduction to Jeffrey Bussgang, a partner at a Boston firm now known as Flybridge Capital Partners. Flybridge and two other firms invested $8 million in Brontes. In 2006, 3M bought the technology for $95 million and late last year it began the national rollout of a $29,900 product called the Lava Chairside Oral Scanner.

(While 3M does not break out the scanners’ financial performance, it said that about 1,000 had been sold and that it employs about 125 people to manufacture and distribute them.)

Mr. Bussgang, who has since invested in four other companies created at the Deshpande Center, says the proof-of-concept model “is a much better use of federal dollars than so many of the other ways the government is trying to prop up industry.”

Ms. Holly is now a vice provost and executive director of the Stevens Institute for Innovation at the University of Southern California, where a program called Ideas Empowered started in May. It has begun seeking proposals from faculty members interested in commercializing their research.

Congress has yet to allocate the proof-of-concept funding, but a House subcommittee held hearings this month on improving “innovation ecosystems” around universities to encourage the commercialization of taxpayer-financed research.

For his part, Professor Hart hopes that all of this will gather even greater momentum.

“The public’s paying for all these wonderful innovations that are just sitting in the drawer,” he says, “because there’s no way for them to make the leap to the commercial world.”

Posted by alevine at 12:04 PM

Email This

Comments (87)

Trackback (0)

Related topics:

Economic Development

Comment on this blog entry Name Email Address URL Remember personal info?	Comments (You may use HTML tags for style)
	Please keep comments free from degrading comments, profanity, and personal attacks.

No comments found.


	Renato Sabater

Talia Bernhardt said


	amazing article!

Zdjęcia koni said


	Staying ahed from the game enterprise wise signifies picking out a excellent company design - one particular that scales with no large expenses and generates ongoing returns that aren't tied directly to work (it's challenging to make consulting scale this way, even though not impossible). It's also vital to have a fantastic merchandise - one thing that genuinely positive aspects your users/buyers. This implies supplying solutions that present high ROI or that efficiently speak to some essential company (or if you're going consumer - human) will need.

ESSIE said


	Follow you dont have to reinvent the wheel

David Casey said


	I still haven't decided what DSLR I like the best. Cannon, Sony, and Samsung all make decent cameras. Who has the best lenses?

Jaimie Peterson said


	Hello there, Where was this weblog when I started blogging 4 years ago?! Seriously this web site would have lowered the level of study I had to perform as I went about my blogging lifestyle. It'd possibly also have helped me to make a acceptable revenue sooner as well.

Celsa Klyn said


	Excellent job.

cheap travel said


	I really enjoyed the post. It proved to be Extremely very helpful to me and I am positive to every one of the commentators right here!

Quincy Canario said


	Very valuable details shared..Iam really happy to go through this post..thanks for giving us good information.Wonderful walk-through. I love this post.

Isaac Moonshower said


	Wow!This can be amazing,almost as well significantly to digest. Good function.

Van Sievertsen said


	Excellent job.

travel resort said


	I usually read the content on blogs prior to when I leave a brief review. If I have next to nothing to say about the write-up topic, I might not leave any observations. And I'm keen to read someone else’s reviews on that post as well. Because I'll find useful ideas from the quality comments. I'd have posted “Good blog! Good posts!” then I might possibly be spamming your blog. I too make use of a blog page, first thing I'd personally do everyday after i signed on my web log is find out more about feedback to my blogposts and personally approve or reject these observations. Keywordluv not only brings you more commenters. It enhances your position in search engines being you’re not only on countless “dofollow blog lists” but additionally on a variety of those “keywordluv lists”. Thanks, Pat

Willian Klar said


	As being a beginner blogger personally, certainly nice you just read a decent blogger for something new. I intend to find out a lot from scanning some others personal blogs and Personally i think that yours has very much to offer the subscriber, thanks a lot for finding the time and making the effort. Deirdre

Ethelyn Gabardi said


	This is certainly a premier contribution. I've a related weblog myself so I might keep coming back to learn more. cheers for this sort of a gratifying valuable experience. Julie

Freeman Wyrosdick said


	I've got to assert, that in all the time I have spent using the web, looking through web logs, I’ve never read one as helpful and well written as this one, I don't usually comment on information sites yet for you personally I felt the need to make an exception, it's truthfully superior work and wholly opposite to the drivel, i spend much of my time on the internet, reading. Appreciate it for finding the time and investing the effort to supply your readers with a 1st class posting. I look forward to reading much more of your work, once more thanks. Ann

Jovan Eisenhauer said


	Spect for the post pal, are you a professional. I think it is so. Thanks, Gabby

Verda Wontor said


	I seriously like efforts which you have directed at this stuff. I'm excited for your next write-up.Please that I recently found this an informative and interesting blog. I just now hope you could create another post springing out of this. This really is effectively worth reading.

Lauren Polowy said


	You actually raise the right points, still It looks like your ultimate analysis is simply off base, superb stuff though, congratulations are in order. Valerie

Wade Reisenauer said


	Beautifully written piece friend. I only usually find unreadable drivel, when I am scanning the net however this article is like a breath of fresh air to me. Thanks to you for taking the time to expose this info to myself and your other readers. Betty.

Viola Zelasco said


	Well done, gay and lesbian community and its sympathizers. I am inspired by you putting up such powerful opposition to proposition 8, and I am pleased it was overturned.

Steven Sharp said


	great story

touchdown jesus said


	I had a website about this topic, but it attracted so many spam comments I had to close it. You seem to have a better spam filter! Congratulations!

Molly Wedell said


	Very good article! I think to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the tomorrow as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own BlogEngine blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.This is to be honest a Great knowledge gaining post and all thanks to google search engine get me on here. I loved reading your writing and added to the favorites.Very good!

metastatic breast cancer to liver said


	WOWZAA!! Great post, i belive blog posts like this add so much value to the marketing community,i have learnt some valuable info from you. Keep it Up! ;) me and my friend Rob B teach all my students shocking secrets on how to cash in using their blogs on auto-pilot and make few hundred dollars a day. i teach them basic hiddent tactics from blogging, Catch ya later - Julie 'Pro Blogger' J.

Julie 'Pro Blogger' J said


	Thank you for a great post

Best work from home jobs said


	Hands down one of the greatest blog posts I have read in a while. I totally agree with your views and am happy to find other like minded people on the net!

social networking software said


	Great post!

internet marketing said


	Wonderful to read!

Online Colleges said


	don't purchase the ice cream sandwiches. style genuine artificial (because they are)and they are so thin. best to shop for elsewhere.

Get Dairy Queen coupons said


	Wonderful to read!

Marion Chiropractor said


	Great post!

Boston Plumbing said


	Why didn’t I find this post earlier? Keep up the good work!

Electronic Cigarette Free said


	You actually raise some good points, still , I'm sure all your analysis might be off base, solid submit though, best wishes. Anna

Annabel Ditton said


	And stop using that lame leftist straw man to try to justify it. No one has told the Muslims that they can’t build a mosque. Those of us who oppose are saying “don’t do it THERE.” There are zoning ordinances across the nation that dictate where various businesses and other organizations can build. This is no different. There has already been discussion in NY about allowing this bunch to put the mosque somewhere else. But now that Obama has (again) stuck his nose in where it doesn’t belong, things are escalating out of control.

Shirley Benzinger said


	Good post, thanks

internet marketing ebook said


	Thank you for a great post

Best work at home job said


	Great post!

Outrank.com reviews said


	In an attempt to combat rubbish spamming within my web log, I might insert a modest disclaimer adjacent to the comment box. I should probably let the blogging site readers be certain that I encourage these people to publicize their very own services provided they add some suitable information connected to the article. I do not mind doing work a little bit with the intention to gain a good quality link.

Divina Wassink said


	Thanks for the read, I will bookmark it and come back later to check out some of your other posts =)

Ab Circle said


	That's a good post!

Florance Caddy said


	I like your writing skill! Still though you are able to append some things to improve it.

nikoncamera said


	Thanks for your visiting this www.watchau.com/Swiss-Replica-Rolex online store.

Swiss Replica Watches said


	I have to mention, that out of all time I've spent using the web, looking through blogs, I’ve never read one as to the point and well crafted as this one, I don't normally comment on blogs and forums though in your case I felt the need to make an exception, this is certainly in fact top quality work and certainly opposite to the drivel, which i spend a lot of my time on line, reading. Thank you with regard to taking the time and investing your effort to provide your readers with a first class blog. I look forward to reading way more of your work, once again cheers. Deborah

Erick Gonzalis said


	Genuinely truly beneficial weblog article which has got me considering. I never looked at this from your point of view.

never fail list building bonus said


	the articles on this publish is really one particular of the most beneficial substance that We have actually appear throughout. I really like your article, I will are available again to examine for new posts.

never fail list building system review said


	This kind of is 1 of the most reliable article that My spouse and i have checked out till date on this important topic. Really complete nevertheless to the point whilst not having any sort of fluff.

never fail list building bonus said


	Custom Brand Best Electronic Cigarettes - Try it yourself !

esmokes taxes said


	Great post!

travel tickets said


	Please let me know if you're looking for a writer for your blog. You have some really good articles and I think I would be a good asset.

Free Electronic Cigarette said


	This has genuinely sparked up an idea in my mind. That is a wonderful web site submit.

Waldo Recksiek said


	While the primary motivation for most customers is affordable dental care, for some people it's a great opportunity to combine dental care with traveling / vacation. Given the low cost of road, rail and air travel, you can even bring your friends or family along. Also, dental appointments don't take much time so lodging expenses are also low. It's not unheard of of Americans flocking dental offices in Mexico for cheap dental work during a weekend trip. http://www.dentaldestinationsdds.com

Santiago Gawlak said


	Our dental partners will work with your schedule and timeframe to ensure quick access to care. Through Dental Destinations DDS sophisticated online quote system, your dental and medical records will be made accessible to the dental provider of your choice instantly and hence will be able to get your quote within two business days in most cases. http://www.dentaldestinationsdds.com

Irmgard Paco said


	Wow! This can be one particular of the very best blogs We have actually occur throughout on this subject. Basically Magnificent

never fail list building review said


	Very special!!! Bookmarked this page that has this cool important info. Will come back to see if there are any updates. You, the author, are a master. Thanks

never fail list building system said


	Dental tourism is not always a good option. Along with the cost savings on the treatment, you should also consider the time required as well as the number of visitations needed for your specific case. Sometimes, travel costs may outweigh the potential savings in which case it makes dental tourism not worthwhile. If you need braces, for example, which require frequent adjustment by your orthodontist, it may be a better idea to seek help at home unless you live close to the border and your dental clinic in Mexico is at a 30-minute ride. The dental tourism destination you choose can also be a major factor in how much you are able to save. So though you may want to get a quick dental bleaching while you are on a holiday to Turkey, you may not want to go there especially for teeth whitening. Again you wouldn't normally want to pack your bags and head down to Mexico for your half yearly dental cleaning costing less than a hundred dollars at home. But, when you need major dental work like full mouth reconstruction or jaw surgery, dental tourism to India can save you thousands of dollars. If you have to get a couple of small and big dental procedures done at the same time, like dental bonding, root canal treatment or gum treatment, tooth contouring and reshaping, dental fillings composite and smile designing, it may pay to get your dental work abroad. http://www.dentaldestinationsdds.com

Junie Zaczek said


	I usually read the article on sites ahead of when I leave a comment or short. If I have not a single thing to say about the blog post topic, I probably won't leave any comments. And I favor to read someone else’s reviews on that post as well. Because I can also find great ideas among the professional comments. I'd have posted “Nice blog! Really good posts!” then I might possibly be spamming your blog. I also possess blog, the first thing I'd personally do day-to-day once i signed on to my weblog is read feedback to my content articles and by hand approve or reject these opinions. Keywordluv as well as brings you more commenters. It promotes your position in search engines because you’re not merely on so many “dofollow blog lists” but additionally on a handful of those “keywordluv lists”. Thank you, Cheryl

Vanilla Ice said


	Wonderful to read!

internet marketing ebook said


	Very well put together article and site, I can really see this site taking off even more, great job

Rich Klopfer said


	Thank you for a great post

Internet Marketing Services said


	Excellent job.

Business Startup Funding said


	Good post, thanks

Headboards For Beds said


	Thank you for a great post

Press Release Website List said


	Thank you for a great post

Best work from home jobs said


	Good post, thanks

Quick Auto Insurance said


	I used to have a site on this subject, but it attracted so many spam comments I had to shut it. You appear to have a better spam filter! Congratulations!

Steve Vanboven said


	Having been the director of a green business for the last two years, its really refreshing to see information on the net that really helps people become more in tune with ways to minimalise their impact on the environment. Im so over huge companies greenwashing customers into buying their latest fad.

Green Cleaning Services said


	You basically saved me atleast 1 hour of time. I am making a project on this topic and your blog post has helped me through one of the topics of my project. I will browse to the other pages now.

zero cost commissions said


	I am so happy to read this. This is the kind of resources that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that is at the other blogs. Thanks for this precious way of seeing things.

zero cost commissions said


	hey. I just stumbled upon incomparable web publication and also I need to state that this valuable is a fantastic posting. Bless you just for this particular awesome info.

zero cost commissions said


	Terrific piece of writing, I share the same views. I wonder why this universe truly does not picture for a moment just like me and additionally the internet page creator :D

zero cost commissions said


	Definitely a very good piece of writing mate in this particular subject. I have been wanting to know if I can use this write up on my own blog, I can link it back aimed at your website though. If it is very difficult you need to inform me and I most certainly will take it down without delay. Angy

Wilbur Tuesburg said


	This is useful! How did you learn this stuff when you were first getting into it?

Cherelle Modha said


	Wonderful to read!

Arvada Lock said


	Good post, thanks

Harvard remodeling said


	Wonderful to read!

San Angelo Plumbing said


	Wonderful to read!

Bellaire chiropractor said


	Great post!

Gainesville Floors said


	Great post!

cheap holiday insurance said


	Wonderful to read!

Powder Springs cleaning service said


	i thought this was a really great post to read. i'll check back for new posts by you!

Stefan Warshauer said


	Excellent job.

Powder Springs cleaning service said


	Thank you for a great post

Fort Lee chiropractor said


	All the best to Michael Douglas on his cancer. We all hope for a fast recovery. All our prayers go out to Michael Douglas.

Gregory Despain said


	All the best to Michael Douglas on his throat cancer. We all hope for a speedy recovery. All our prayers go out to Michael Douglas.

Andrew Pelt said


	Good post, thanks

Rancho Cucamonga Cleaning Service said


	Great post!

Christiana Carpet Cleaning said


	Why is Building a Mosque at Ground Zero currently being permitted to take place? I've never heard anything at all so utterly bizarre in all of my entire life. If this really comes to fact, It will probably be the worst thing of all time. violet

Kimberly Greem said

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.dc-intl.com/mt1/mt-tb.cgi/175

Andy Levine

June 28, 2010 12:04 PM

The Idea Incubator Goes to Campus June 28, 2010

Leave a comment

The Idea Incubator Goes to Campus
June 28, 2010